Reviews»TV Shows»The Walking Dead:…
the-walking-dead-episode-504-beth-kinney-935-2
Kareem Ali 3.5

The Walking Dead: Slabtown

 

  • The good

    Noah's character development. Very intriguing ending

  • The bad

    Beth's captors came off as either confused, annoying or aimless. Not much action. Felt off throughout

  • The ugly

  • The Walking Dead: Slabtown is the 4th episode of the season and has Beth facing a terrible ordeal in a hospital in Atlanta after being kidnapped by a mysterious group. It opens up with Beth waking up in a hospital attached to an IV with dressing on some apparent wounds she received, and she can’t recall how she got them or how she ended up in this hospital. After checking out her immediate surroundings, Beth is met by a woman named Dawn and Dr. Edwards, who claim they found her injured on the side of the road. And Dawn tells her that since they treated her injuries she owes them. Since money doesn’t have any value in this world any longer, they want Beth to pay them back through service, and she can’t leave until she performs enough duties to equal her treatment. However, everything she uses or eats counts against her and would only make her stay longer so it’s seemingly a no-win situation. And Beth is tasked to be Dr. Edwards assistant, which means she just follows everything he tells her to do while he’s operating, and she’s a witness as another patient dies due to his wounds. Since the medical supplies are limited, they can only do so much for patients and Dawn makes the call for when a patient is too far gone to administer any care. Beth might not have to worry about any walkers while in the hospital but there’s one officer, Gorman, who makes thinly veiled threats at her, making it clear that he has no problem with abusing his power in this situation. There are others, like Noah, a fellow hospital ward, who can’t leave either and understand her predicament. But what’s really going on in the hospital with people being brought in with injuries consistent with trying to escape, and was Beth found on the side of the road or are those in the hospital also responsible for her kidnapping?

    the-walking-dead-episode-504-lerner-woods-edwards-jensen-935
    This season has been on such a roll with great story progression, character development, and of course action. The only thing that’s been missing has been an answer to who took Beth and what happened to her. Even though I was anxious to know what happened to her, this episode made me feel that an entire episode didn’t have to be dedicated to her current predicament. It’s not that Beth was a problem, even though I felt that this episode ignored some of her character development at the end of last season, it’s that this episode rehashed so many themes done better in previous episodes and seasons that it wasn’t engrossing. Now, I understand the importance of story and character development in a series, and last season had many excellent episodes that focused on the latter. The episode that focused on Beth last season is part of what made me feel some of that was undone here. And I even have some thoughts on what was really going on here, and what this was connected to based on some of the characters statements so I thought about this episode in many ways. And even if this episode is the start of an amazing story arc, it still could have been executed better. It started off okay with the initial confusion about how Beth ended up in the hospital with Dawn and Dr. Edwards playing it straight. But their “we don’t know you were kidnapped” act started to wear thin very fast because it wasn’t just in front of Beth to keep her confused but they came off just as confused at times. And as a result it was difficult to find a correct context to view everything going on because clearly they had to be connected to Beth’s kidnapping so there was no need to carry this on the entire episode. So they didn’t come off as devious or attempting to use propaganda to manipulate Beth but as disappointingly bad in terms of being menacing.

    the-walking-dead-episode-504-beth-kinney-noah-williams-935
    And I believe part of the problem with this episode was the desire to create 2 cliffhangers, one at the end of last episode and one at the end of this episode. There have been some great cliffhangers this season so I’m not completely against them but last week’s abrupt ending with this week’s forced suspense left this episode in a bad position to just serve as filler. And it’s a shame because there were some positives in this episode such as Noah, played by Tyler James Williams, and his character stood out by far among the new characters. He would help Beth and they would relate to each other based on their current situation and both being underestimated, and they had some really good scenes together. They would plan an escape based on the fact that neither one of them would ever be able to pay back this group holding with their service. Their escape plan would constitute all the action this episode, which was very little. Dr. Edwards’ character development would be the second most intriguing although it felt as if his reason for contributing and staying wasn’t anything new so it didn’t have to be spelled out. Dawn would come off as an unusual character for reasons I already stated about the story. And by far the most annoying would be Gorman, whose actions would be more grating than menacing because it’s an act seen so many times in better ways. So the most this episode did aside from introducing Noah was the very interesting ending that led to speculation about what could happen next week.

    the-walking-dead-episode-504-beth-kinney-gorman-moss-935

    SUMMARY

     

    The Walking Dead: Slabtown was a very ho-hum episode that explored many issues that were addressed much better in other episodes, and as a result was just a tease of what’s to come. The perplexing manner in which Beth’s captors talked to and dealt with her made them come off as confused individuals and not part of a larger group that has a mantra. I enjoyed Noah’s introduction and I’m looking forward to seeing what’s in store for him, and I’m curious as to what the group’s ultimate goal is since that wasn’t clearly addressed. And I felt the episode that focused on Beth last season was a much better one with this episode ignoring some of those developments. However, I’m looking forward to the next episode due to the intriguing conclusion, and hopefully it’ll be more exciting.

  • Rating ( 7 )
  • Total score 7.0

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: